User avatar
august 🇲🇰🏳️‍⚧️ @august@transmasc.social
2w
also as it seems this point has to be made again (and somehow people seem to be confused that my profile states that using they/them is considered misgendering)

using they/them for people that don't use they/them pronouns that have told you their pronouns is called degendering and it's a form of misgendering

it happens a lot to transmascs specifically, as we time and time again get painted as 'confused/hysteric women'

if it happens around you,
call it out.
:akko_hug@brain.worm.pink:1:neofox_heart@fuzzyfox.social:1:purple_flame_heart@catwithaclari.net:1❤️4💜1
5
47
78
8

User avatar
Jackie @jackielovescompchem32@scicomm.xyz
2w
@august oh it's not specific to trans men/mascs. Trans women experience it a lot.
1
0
0
0
User avatar
august 🇲🇰🏳️‍⚧️ @august@transmasc.social
2w
@jackielovescompchem32 i literally didn't make any statement about transfems, i also didn't state anywhere that it happens exclusively to transmascs/trans men
1
0
3
0
User avatar
Jackie @jackielovescompchem32@scicomm.xyz
2w
@august

"it happens a lot to transmascs specifically, as we time and time again get painted as 'confused/hysteric women'"

Words have meaning, bro
0
0
0
0
User avatar
NatalyaD @NatalyaD@disabled.social
2w
@august I also hate when organisations are lazy and just "they/them" everyone.

I see it a lot in my work where I work with disabled students at university. The university does it for 'template documents' and disability student assessments and medical letters often have it. When I was a disability assessor my boss rightly didn't allow it and I won't either!

Drives me nuts. Also means I can't tell if someone is a genuine they/them or the document is just lazily authored.
2
0
1
0
User avatar
Sheikh @cybardev@techhub.social
2w
@NatalyaD @august these (this comment and the parent post) are some nuanced takes. thanks.

i always thought that it would be nice to dissolve the entire concept of gender and just unite in our shared humanity, but i see that maybe that is not the case. especially since we live in a traditionally gendered world, and since we can't instantly remove all the gender barriers, etc. all at once, it's better to conform how the individuals prefer, rather than making anyone uncomfortable by using ungendered pronouns.

also, my native language has only "they/them" pronouns without binary gender like English and many other languages, so maybe some bias comes from there too (oddly enough, people in my country are very gender-conforming, and bigoted; one of the reasons i left when i could. usually one would think language would have some influence on the minds but maybe not...)

this has given me some food for thought
0
0
1
0
User avatar
Tattie @Tattie@eldritch.cafe
2w
@NatalyaD the most hilarious consequence of a they/them template I've seen was at work when I received an email reading:
Please welcome Jim Jimson to the company! Please assist him however you can in the next few days while they find his feet.
@august
3
0
2
0
User avatar
econads @econads@mendeddrum.org
2w
@Tattie
That's creepy. Like someone's going around looking at this guy's feet? Or the feet are detached?

@NatalyaD @august
1
0
1
0
User avatar
Tattie @Tattie@eldritch.cafe
2w
@econads Cowörker, by IKEA. Some assembly required.
@NatalyaD @august
1
0
1
0
User avatar
NatalyaD @NatalyaD@disabled.social
2w
@Tattie That's hilarious and demonstrates the issue perfectly. @august
0
0
0
0
User avatar
Acin ☆ @shadowfals@toot.cat
2w
@Tattie that switching of pronouns is appropriate for some who are genderfluid, genderqueer, or agender. It's specifically requested.

I guess you found out later Jim Jimson only uses he/him?

@NatalyaD @august
1
0
1
0
User avatar
Tattie @Tattie@eldritch.cafe
2w
@shadowfals I feel this specific usage changes the meaning of the sentence since it no longer seems reflexive (?).
Changing pronoun on a sentence by sentence basis might be safest for avoiding ambiguity.

(Edit: and yeah, the pronouns were consistently he/him thru the rest of the email. I was the first person in that company to adopt they/them pronouns as far as I know, which was met with some bemusement.)
@NatalyaD @august
0
0
1
0
User avatar
Freja @freja@freja.zone
2w
@august oh yeah i've seen the same point shared around in the form of this post
0
0
1
0
User avatar
cn (old) ->dhcp nonbinary @cancername@mas.to
2w
@august yep, that's the right approach. this is one of the cases where there are conflicting goals, in general we want to degender language to reduce the harmful effects of gender, but we also want trans people to be treated as the gender they are and work against their erasure.
0
0
1
0
User avatar
Staraven1 (she/her) @Staraven1@transfem.social
1w
@august to me, the big thing is they/them pronouns are not misgendering by default (and may not be the worst default), they only become so, as u said, once u know the person would prefer otherwise...
(tho i think the matt parker approach to "incusive academic language"-like gendering everyone always only neutrally and with they/them be they cis or trans is the only ok exception but i am open to critism on that take)
0
0
1
0